Managing performance and behavioral issues is challenging in any workplace, but when a disability is involved, the stakes are much higher.
As an employer, you must balance accountability and compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to ensure your organization is headed in the right direction. Understanding how to discipline an employee with disabilities appropriately is critical to avoiding legal risk while sending the right message to the rest of your workforce.
This article breaks down what you as an employer need to know, from performance standards to conduct rules, accommodation requests, and best practices.
The Americans with Disabilities Act, or ADA, is a law that protects “qualified individuals with disabilities" by ensuring they have access to equal employment opportunities. It applies to private employers with 15 or more employees and is enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
To understand what this law requires, we need to break down the terms. According to the ADA's definition, a “qualified” employee is a person who can perform the essential job functions, with or without a reasonable accommodation. A disability is then defined as:
So if someone has a disability but is able to perform the essential functions (necessary job duties) of the job with the help of an accommodation, then the ADA protects them from discrimination.
Examples of an employee with a disability who might need an accommodation include:
If any of these conditions were to be considered when making an employment decision (such as hiring, firing, job assignments, etc.), that would be considered disability discrimination. For example, if you do not consider an employee for a promotion that has epilepsy or diabetes or uses a wheelchair — but they are otherwise qualified — then you may be in violation of disability discrimination.
One of the most important principles when you discipline an employee with disabilities is this: Employees with disabilities must meet the same performance standards as everyone else. Each employee's performance should be evaluated using the same criteria for all those performing the same job.
This includes:
These standards apply to both quantity and quality of work. Employers have the right to discipline or terminate employees with disabilities for poor performance, as long as the same evaluation criteria are used for all employees in the same job.
If an employee receives a poor performance rating, even if it's due to a disability, the rating should stand. Employers may need to provide accommodations that help the employee meet performance requirements, but lowering standards is not considered a reasonable accommodation.
A reasonable accommodation is an adjustment the employer makes that allows an employee to access equal employment opportunities and/or to perform the essential job duties of the position. Common reasonable accommodations include:
Per the ADA, employers must provide reasonable accommodations to enable employees with disabilities to meet performance standards unless doing so would cause an undue hardship.
An undue hardship is something that incurs significant difficulty or expense beyond minor inconvenience or modest cost. These requests are evaluated individually and take into account the company's size, financial needs, operational needs, and whether the accommodation request would fundamentally alter business operations.
When you discipline an employee with disabilities, the ADA does not require you to:
Remember, the same conduct standards apply to those with disabilities as those without.
Employers retain broad authority to enforce conduct rules and policies that are job-related and consistent with business necessity, even when a disability is involved. Specific conduct standards should be clearly defined and applied equally to all employees, including those with disabilities.
While they are not required to excuse misconduct or lower production standards due to a disability, employers must ensure employees have the necessary tools to meet expectations.
You can discipline an employee with disabilities for misconduct, even if the behavior is caused by the disability, when the rule is job-related, consistent with business necessity, and applied equally to all employees.
Demonstrating appropriate customer service and respect is essential, especially when serving customers and/or treating customers with courtesy. Unacceptable behavior, such as disrespect or inappropriate physical contact, may be subject to disciplinary action.
Even when misconduct is linked to a disability, discipline is still allowed if it violates job-related standards. Remember:
However, consistency is critical. Employers must avoid harsher discipline for disabled employees and selective enforcement of rules.
If an employee discloses a disability when a supervisor counsels them about performance issues and the employee requests accommodation during that meeting, how should the supervisor respond?
The supervisor does not need to rescind discipline, delay termination, or ignore past misconduct.
The EEOC provides practical guidance on the interactive process, offering clear steps for employers and employees to address performance and conduct issues related to disabilities.
When an accommodation is requested, or when an employee believes their conduct problem is related to a disability, employers should engage in a collaborative discussion to determine:
Employers must engage in the interactive process to determine whether a reasonable accommodation is needed when an employee indicates that a conduct problem is related to a disability. The employer may request limited medical documentation when necessary (and job-related).
Any medical information disclosed during the interactive process must be kept confidential and stored separately from the employee's personnel file.
Attendance is typically an essential job function. However, accommodations may include modified schedules, intermittent leave, and adjusted start/end times. You do not have to allow indefinite leave, accept chronic, unpredictable absenteeism, or eliminate attendance requirements entirely.
If attendance issues existed before an accommodation request, discipline may still apply.
As an employer, you should never interfere with medical decisions. Do not require employees to take medication or suggest specific treatments. Instead, focus on job performance, workplace behavior, and/or possible accommodations.
When discussing problems, the focus should be on performance or conduct — not the employee's disability. When a supervisor warns an employee about performance or conduct issues, clearly explain job expectations and ask if any support is needed. Let the employee bring up their medical condition if they want to discuss it.
The ADA distinguishes between alcoholism, which may be protected, and current illegal drug use, which is not protected.
Employees with substance use issues are subject to the same discipline and conduct standards as other employees. An employee whose poor performance or conduct is due to current illegal drug use is not protected under the ADA.
Employers may:
In some cases, employers may offer an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) or a last chance agreement.
Employers must keep disability-related information confidential. Managers should never disclose accommodations to coworkers or explain schedule changes or exceptions.
To reduce risk and ensure fairness when disciplining someone with disabilities, keep the following best practices in mind.
Treat all employees the same under performance and conduct standards.
Keep detailed records of:
Address issues before they escalate. Early conversations can prevent larger problems. For example, a manager might explain to an employee with a disability how workplace conduct rules apply and discuss possible accommodations to help the employee meet those standards.
Focus on job expectations and outcomes — not assumptions about medical conditions.
Explore accommodations in good faith.
Ensure supervisors understand ADA obligations and proper communication strategies.
Employers absolutely can discipline an employee with disabilities — and in many cases, they should. The ADA does not require lowering standards or tolerating misconduct.
What it does require is fairness, including:
By following these principles, employers can maintain accountability while staying compliant and create a workplace that is both inclusive and high-performing. For more tips on how to apply this at your workplace, please contact your certified HR expert.
Not a current Stratus HR client? Book a free consultation and our team will contact you shortly.