Every manager eventually encounters a difficult personality. It might be the employee who challenges every decision, the coworker who turns every conversation into an argument, the person who constantly plays the victim, or someone who seems to thrive on creating conflict.
Some people are simply frustrating to work with while others demonstrate more challenging behaviors (think manipulation, blame-shifting, controlling tendencies, chronic negativity, or narcissistic traits).
The natural reaction is often to become defensive, argue back, or avoid the person altogether. Unfortunately, these responses rarely resolve the situation and affect everyone's well-being.
Experienced therapists and conflict-resolution professionals use techniques that help people navigate difficult interactions without losing control of their emotions. Managers can apply many of these same principles to maintain professional authority, establish boundaries, and keep workplace relationships productive.
As you read the strategies below, keep in mind that the goal isn't to change a difficult person's personality or win every argument but to learn how to respond with confidence, skill, and emotional intelligence.
One of the most valuable conflict resolution skills in dealing with difficult people is controlling your own emotional response.
When someone is disrespectful or confrontational, it's easy to react defensively. However, responding while emotionally charged can lead to poor decisions and unnecessary conflict.
Psychologists refer to the ability to recognize and manage emotional reactions as emotional regulation and plays a key role in personal growth.
Before responding to a provocative comment, the American Psychiatric Association suggests you:
You cannot control what someone says but you can control what you do next.
Another person's behavior is often more reflective of their own beliefs, insecurities, expectations, and experiences than it is of you. For example, a chronically critical employee may feel threatened by change, an argumentative coworker may have a strong need for control, and someone who constantly seeks approval may be operating from insecurity.
Understanding this doesn't excuse inappropriate behavior but helps you avoid internalizing every negative interaction.
Instead of asking, "Why are they treating me this way?" ask:
For example, if an employee responds to feedback with, "Nobody here appreciates anything I do," resist the urge to defend yourself.
Instead, say, "I understand you feel your contributions aren't being recognized. Let's talk about that. I also want to address the missed deadlines we discussed."
You can acknowledge someone's feelings without accepting their interpretation of events.
Reflective listening is a technique used in counseling and motivational interviewing. It involves repeating the underlying message in your own words to demonstrate understanding.
Suppose an employee says, "Management never listens to us. You make decisions without caring what anyone thinks."
Rather than responding, "That's not true," try saying something like, “It sounds like you feel decisions are being made without enough input from the team."
Other useful phrases include:
Acknowledging someone's perspective doesn't mean you agree with their accusations but shows you understand where they’re coming from.
Open-ended questions help people examine their own thoughts and motivations. Managers can use this technique to move coworkers' conversations away from accusations and toward solutions.
If an employee says, "This entire project is going to fail," ask, "What specifically makes you concerned about the outcome?"
When someone says, "Nobody else is doing their job," ask, "Which responsibilities do you believe aren't being completed?"
If an employee insists a decision is unfair, ask, "What would a fair outcome look like to you?"
Avoid questions that sound like personal attacks, such as "Why are you always so negative?" The objective is to encourage constructive discussion, not put someone on the defensive.
Some recurring behaviors interfere with accountability and communication. As a manager, you should recognize patterns such as:
Suppose an employee misses a deadline and says, "If the rest of the team actually communicated, this wouldn't have happened." Instead of debating who is at fault, say, "Let's discuss the communication issue separately. Right now, I want to understand why the deadline was missed and what needs to happen to complete the project."
Stay calm and keep the conversation focused on facts and responsibilities.
Managers sometimes spend too much time justifying their decisions, defending expectations, and trying to convince difficult employees that a boundary is reasonable.
But professional boundaries don't require universal agreement.
Examples of clear, direct language include:
A boundary should establish what behavior you will participate in and what action you will take if the behavior continues.
The grey rock method is an informal communication strategy that involves keeping interactions brief, neutral, and factual when someone repeatedly seeks an emotional reaction – which is especially useful for coworkers who thrive on arguments, sarcasm, or unnecessary drama.
This method should not be used as a punishment like stonewalling someone and should never be used in cases of harassment, discrimination, threats, or legitimate employee concerns. It’s meant for minor provocations and repetitive, unproductive interactions to prevent you from engaging emotionally.
Examples of using the grey rock method might include:
Instead of defending yourself or matching their energy, simply avoid reacting with an emotional response.
The JADE principle is a communication concept commonly used in discussions about high-conflict relationships. It encourages people to avoid getting trapped in excessive justification, arguing, defending, and explaining.
As a manager, you might believe that if you explain a decision thoroughly enough, even the most resistant employee will eventually agree.
That isn't always the case.
Instead of repeatedly explaining why an employee didn't receive a promotion, be clear with your explanation. For example, "The position was awarded based on the qualifications and performance criteria established for the role. I'm happy to discuss development opportunities for future advancement."
You should still answer reasonable questions and provide appropriate transparency to meet expectations. The key is recognizing when a productive explanation has turned into an unproductive argument.
Silence is one of the most underused communication tools available to managers. People often feel uncomfortable with silence and rush to fill it. In difficult conversations, this can lead to over-explaining, unnecessary concessions, or emotional reactions on behalf of the manager.
After asking a challenging question, wait.
For example: "You've mentioned several times that the workload is unreasonable. What specific changes would make it manageable?"
Don't immediately offer solutions or answer the question for them.
Strategic silence gives people time to process their thoughts and encourages more thoughtful responses. It should never be used to punish or deliberately intimidate employees.
One of the biggest mistakes managers make is spending too much time trying to change an employee's personality.
You may not be able to make someone more positive, agreeable, humble, or considerate. However, you can establish expectations for how they behave at work.
|
Instead of saying... |
Address the behavior |
|
"You're argumentative" |
"You interrupted three colleagues during today's meeting." |
|
"You're negative" |
"You raised concerns without offering alternatives." |
|
"You're selfish" |
"You changed the shared schedule without consulting the team." |
|
"You're disrespectful" |
"You made personal comments about a coworker during a meeting." |
Specific behaviors are easier to discuss, measure, and improve.
Managers often feel responsible for resolving every conflict and making every employee satisfied. But there is a difference between being an effective leader and allowing someone else's behavior to consume your time and energy.
Whether the other person struggles with mental health, is passive aggressive, or is simply one of the most difficult people you've ever worked with, be aware of these warning signs:
Try ending the conversation constructively:
"I think we've covered the main points. I've explained the expectations and next steps. Let's move forward, and we can revisit the issue if new information becomes available."
Disengaging from an unproductive argument is a decision to use your time and attention effectively.
Communication strategies are valuable, but they aren't a substitute for management accountability. You may need to seek support with formal intervention for some workplace behaviors, such as:
When an employee repeatedly violates expectations, document details that include:
Work with HR to ensure the response is consistent, appropriate, and aligned with company policies and employment laws.
Also distinguish between inappropriate conduct and legitimate employee complaints or legally protected activity. An employee should not be labeled difficult simply because they disagree with management or raise a concern.
The most effective managers aren't necessarily the ones who are best at winning arguments or getting everyone to like them. They're the ones who:
Dealing with difficult people requires emotional intelligence, self-awareness, clear communication, and consistent accountability.
You may never be able to change the person sitting across from you. But you can change how you respond, how you establish expectations, and how much influence their behavior has over your day.
That's where real leadership power begins.
For more articles, tips, or insight, please contact your Stratus HR rep. Not a Stratus HR client? Book a free consultation and our team will contact you shortly.
Sources:
American Psychiatric Association (When Emotions Feel Overwhelming: Understanding Emotional Regulation)
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)
Society for Human Resource Management (The Civility at Work Companion Guide)
Society for Human Resource Management (How to Resolve Conflict at Work)
Society for Human Resource Management (Manager's Conflict Handling Decision Guide)